Yes, tree topping is bad for trees. Topping means cutting the top of a tree straight across to make it shorter. The International Society of Arboriculture calls it one of the most harmful pruning practices. It starves the tree, invites decay, and the weak new growth breaks easier in storms. Ask for crown reduction or thinning instead.

Why do people top trees?

Usually to make a tall tree feel safer, or to clear a view or a power line. The problem is that topping increases risk over time. The tree pushes out fast, thin shoots that attach weakly and fail under ice and wind.

What happens to a tree after it is topped?

  • It loses its food supply. Leaves make the tree’s food. Cutting off the top removes much of the leafy crown at once.
  • Big wounds stay open. Large cuts on thick branches are slow to seal, so decay can move in.
  • The regrowth is weak. New shoots grow fast and attach near the surface of the cut, not deep in the wood.
  • It grows back tall anyway. Most topped trees need cutting again, so the cost keeps coming back.

What should I ask for instead?

  • Crown reduction. Shortens branches back to a healthy side branch, so the tree keeps its shape.
  • Crown thinning. Removes select branches so wind passes through.
  • Crown raising. Lifts low limbs off the roof, driveway or sidewalk.
  • Removal. If a tree is truly too big for its spot, removing and replanting can beat topping it again and again.

Timing matters too. Late fall through late winter is the best time to trim most trees in Kansas City. See when to trim trees in Kansas City.

Is a topped tree safe to keep?

Sometimes. A topped tree can often be brought back with a few years of careful pruning that picks the strongest new shoots and removes the weak ones. If decay has spread into the trunk, removal is usually the safer choice. A tree professional should look at it in person.

Get it trimmed the right way with Master’s Tree Care Experts

Master’s Tree Care Experts trims trees to keep their natural shape, not to cut them flat. We shorten and thin crowns, lift limbs off roofs and driveways, and clean up when we are done. If a tree has to come down, we remove it safely and can grind the stump. We work across Overland Park and the Kansas City metro, 24/7, with free quotes.

Comparing tree companies? Read how to find the best tree care before you hire.

Call (913) 909-9768 or get a free quote.

Related: Tree Trimming · Tree Removal

Will a topped tree grow back?

It regrows fast, but the new branches are weakly attached and need more upkeep.

What is the difference between topping and crown reduction?

Topping cuts branches to stubs. Crown reduction cuts back to a healthy side branch.